Narrative and Witz in Physics

Address by Charles H. Holbrow on the occasion of receiving the 2012 Oersted Medal of the AAPT

Abstract

Charles H. HolbrowPhysics is the syntax and grammar of science; it is the rules. Therefore, you must learn physics to write, speak, or do good science. But knowing the rules of physics won’t make you a good physicist or a good physics teacher any more than knowing grammar will make you a good writer. To bring physics alive you need strong narratives and interesting content. I will describe three examples: A course–“The Physics of Living in Space” a textbook–Modern Introductory Physics; and a project–Astronomy’s Discoveries and Physics Education. I will also show examples of what I mean by “Witz” and why it is important in physics.

American Journal of Physics, 80(6), 468-  (2012)

AJP theme issue guest editorial: Use astronomy to teach physics

Modern astronomy and space science have brought us remarkable technologies and astonishing discoveries that excite and engage us all—teachers, students, and the general public.  But it is physics that lets us explore and comprehend the cosmos and its unusual objects, and we need to help our students understand this physics.  This theme issue shows how we might improve this process by using astronomy’s discoveries and technologies as contexts for teaching physics.

How can we use astronomy to teach physics? The articles in this issue suggest answers that are varied and interesting. Implicitly, they also raise some important questions. For one thing, how do you find a focus when there is such a dazzling wealth of material and such a vast range of possibilities? How do you bring your attention to bear on the underlying physics without being swept away by powerful images and narratives? For another thing, physicists need to know astronomy if they are going to use it to teach physics; for many of us this means learning new ideas, new vocabulary, and new ways to look at the Universe and its parts. It may also mean learning some new physics. Continue reading “AJP theme issue guest editorial: Use astronomy to teach physics”

Contents of the AJP theme issue

EDITORIAL — Charles H. Holbrow and Peter Shaffer, Theme Issue Editors
CONTENTS

Author(s) Title
Jodi L. Christiansen & Andrew Siver Computing accurate age and distance factors in cosmology
Colin S. Wallace and Edward E. Prather Teaching physics with Hubble’s law and dark matter
Kevin Krisciunas, Erika DeBenedictus, Jeremy Steeger, Agnes Bischoff-Kim, Gil Tabak, & Kanika Pasricha The First Three Rungs of the Cosmological Distance Ladder
Roy R. Gould, Susan Sunbury, & Ruth Krumhansl Using online telescopes to explore exoplanets from the physics classroom
Gerald T. Ruch & Martin E. Johnston A Robotic Observatory in the City
Benjamin Oostra Measurement of the Earth’s Rotational Speed via Doppler Shift of Solar Absorption Lines
Hsiang-Wen Hsu & Mihaly Horanyi Ballistic motion of dust particles in the Lunar Roving Vehicle dust trails
M. Kaan Ozturk Trajectories of charged particles trapped in Earth’s magnetic field
A. R. P. Rau Topics in quantum physics with origins in astronomy: Two examples
Jonathan M. Marr & Francis P. Wilkin A Better Presentation of Planck’s Law Through Average Photon Energy and Spectral Energy Distributions
Ronald J. Adler Cosmogenesis and the tipping pencil analogy
Davide Cenadelli, Marco Petenza, and Mauro Zeni Stellar temperatures via Wien’s Law: Not so simple
Richard H. Price & Joseph D. Romano In an expanding universe, what doesn’t expand?
Friedman A Grand and Bold Thing, Ann Finkbeiner. 223 pp. Free Press, New York, 2010. Price $27.00 (cloth) ISBN 978-1-4165-5216-1

Gordon Conference Program

PROGRAM  June 17-22, 2012

PHYSICS RESEARCH & EDUCATION GORDON RESEARCH CONFERENCE

SUNDAY

2:00 pm – 8:00 pm Arrival and check-in
(Office Closed 6:00 pm – 7:00 pm)

6:00 pm – 7:15 pm  Dinner

7:30 pm – 7:40 pm  Welcome / Introductory Comments by GRC Site Staff

7:40 pm – 9:30 pm The Physics in Astronomy’s Discoveries and Technologies
Discussion Leader: Charles H. Holbrow (Colgate U / MIT)

7:40 pm – 8:20 pm  Robert Kirshner (Harvard)
“The Energetic Universe”

8:20 pm – 8:35 pm  Discussion

8:35 pm – 9:15 pm  Noah Finkelstein (U Colorado)
“Evolve or Die: Challenges in Physics Education at a Critical Time”

9:15 pm – 9:30 pm Discussion

MONDAY

7:30 am – 8:30 am Breakfast

9:00 am – 12:30 pm Exoplanets: New Worlds – How to find them; what they’re like
Discussion Leader: Sara Seager (MIT)

9:00 am – 9:40 am  David Charbonneau (Harvard)
How the Hunt for Habitable Worlds with Kepler Can Inspire Students in Physics”

9:40 am – 10:00 am Discussion

10:00 am Coffee Break

10:30 am – 11:10 am Doug Caldwell (NASA-SETI)
“Finding and Understanding Exoplanets Using Undergraduate Physics”

11:10 am – 11:30 am Discussion

11:30 am – 12:10 pm  Scott Gaudi (The Ohio State University)
“How to Conduct a Census of Exoplanets”

12:10 pm – 12:30 pm Discussion

12:30 pm Lunch

1:30 pm – 4:00 pm Free Time

4:00 pm – 6:00 pm Poster Session

6:00 pm Dinner

7:30 pm – 9:30 pm  What is Being Done at Smaller Institutions

Discussion Leader: Mario Belloni (Davidson College)

7:30 pm – 7:50 pm  Dan Reichart (UNC Chapel Hill)
“Project Intro Astro:  Skynet Robotic Telescope-Based Labs for Majors
and Non-Majors”

7:50 pm – 8:00 pm Discussion

8:00 pm – 8:20 pm  Larry Marschall (Gettysburg College)
“Astronomical Research in an Undergraduate Setting: Exploring the Real Sky at
Gettysburg College Observatory and the Virtual Sky through Project CLEA”

8:20 pm – 8:30 pm Discussion

8:30 pm – 8:50 pm  Todd Timberlake (Berry College)
“Engaging with the History of Astronomy”

8:50 pm – 9:00 pm Discussion

9:00 pm – 9:20 pm  Wolfgang Christian (Davidson College)
“ComPADRE Digital Library Resources for Teaching Astronomy.”

9:20 pm – 9:30 pm   Discussion

 

TUESDAY

7:30 am – 8:30 am Breakfast

9:00 am – 12:30 pm Observational Cosmology: New Horizons

Discussion Leader: Robert Kirshner (Harvard)

9:00 am – 9:40 am  Tony Tyson (U C Davis)
“Imaging the Invisible:  Optical Instrumentation for Cosmology”

9:40 am – 10:00 am Discussion

10:00 am Coffee Break

10:30 am – 11:10 am  Chris Stubbs (Harvard)
“Why has the discovery of dark energy precipitated a crisis
in fundamental physics?”

11:10 am – 11:30 am Discussion

11:30 am – 12:10 pm  Bryan Penprase (Pomona College)
“Beacons of the Early Universe – Detecting Elements from the First Stars and Galaxies from Quasar
and Gamma-Ray-Burst Spectra”

12:10 pm – 12:30 pm Discussion

12:30 pm Lunch

1:30 pm – 4:00 pm Free Time

 4:00 pm – 6:00 pm Poster Session

6:00 pm Dinner

7:30 pm – 9:30 pm Teaching Physics with Astronomy: What AER & PER tell us

Discussion Leader: Hashima Hasan (NASA)

7:30 pm – 8:00 pm  Ed Prather (U Arizona)
                           “Astronomy Education Research: Providing a framework for integrating our 
understanding of the universe into the physics classroom”

8:00 pm – 8:10 pm Discussion

8:10 pm – 8:40 pm  Seth Hornstein (U Colorado)
                            “Enlivening Physics Education through Astronomy Research:
Extrasolar Planets & Black Holes.”

8:40 pm – 8:50 pm Discussion

8:50 pm – 9:20 pm  Dean Zollman (Kansas State U)
“Context Matters:  Insights from transfer research on teaching
physics with examples from astronomy”

9:20 pm – 9:30 pm Discussion

WEDNESDAY

7:30 am – 8:30 am Breakfast

9:00 am – 12:30 pm Stars and Physics

Discussion Leader: Beth Willman (Haverford College)

9:00 am – 9:40 am     Peter Parker (Yale)
“Stars in the Laboratory”

9:40 am – 10:00 am Discussion

10:00 am Coffee Break

10:30 am – 11:10 am  Amanda Karakas (Australian National University)
“Why we don’t understand the origin of the elements as well
as we think we do!”

11:10 am – 11:30 am  Discussion

11:30 am – 12:10 pm  Andrew West (Boston University)
“The Statistical Power of Billions of Stars:
Stellar and Galactic Astronomy in the Era of Deep All-Sky Surveys”

 12:10 pm – 12:30 pm Discussion

 12:30 pm Lunch

 1:30 pm – 4:00 pm Free Time

 4:00 pm – 6:00 pm Poster Session

6:00 pm Dinner

7:00 pm – 7:30 pm Business Meeting

Nominations for the next Vice Chair; Fill out Conference Evaluation Forms;

Discuss future Site & Scheduling preferences; Election of the next Vice Chair

7:30 pm – 9:30 pm Frontiers of Astronomy’s Instruments & Detectors

Discussion Leader: Randy Peterson (U of the South – Sewanee)

7:30 pm – 8:10 pm  Alan Rogers (MIT Haystack Observatory)
“Examples of Radio Astronomy Instrumentation for research
and education”

8:10 pm – 8:30 pm  Discussion

8:30 pm – 8:50 pm  Paul Bierden (Boston Micromachines Corp.)
“Adaptive Optics for Astronomers & Others”

8:50 pm – 9:00 pm Discussion

 

9:00 pm – 9:20 pm  John Taranto (Thorlabs)
“Adaptive Optics in the Undergraduate Lab”

9:20 pm – 9:30 pm Discussion

THURSDAY

7:30 am – 8:30 am Breakfast

9:00 am – 12:30 pm Gravitational Radiation & Interesting Objects

Discussion Leader: Barbara Ryden (The Ohio State University)

9:00 am – 9:40 am Duncan Brown (Syracuse U)
“The New Astronomy of LIGO”

 9:40 am – 10:00 am Discussion

 10:00 am Coffee Break

10:30 am – 11:10 am Greg Bothun (U Oregon)
“Astronomy:  Data Driven Inquiry to Reveal the Physics”

11:10 am – 11:30 am Discussion

11:30 am – 12:10 pm  Lucy Fortson (U Minnesota)
“The Extreme Universe: The Science and Tools of High Energy
Astrophysics in the Classroom”

12:10 pm – 12:30 pm Discussion

12:30 pm Lunch

1:30 pm – 4:00 pm Free Time

4:00 pm – 6:00 pm Poster Session

6:00 pm Dinner

7:30 pm – 9:30 pm Astronomy Based Materials for Teaching Physics: What should they be? Who will make them?

Discussion Leader: Ed Prather (U Arizona)

7:30 pm – 8:10 pm Rapporteur: Sterl Phinney (Caltech)
“Can astrophysics revitalize physics education?  Should it?”

8:10 pm – 8:30 pm Discussion

8:30 pm           Panel:  Joseph Amato (Colgate U),   Greg Bothun (U Oregon),
Tom O’Kuma 
(Lee College)

“Where do we go next? What will you do to get us there?”

8:45 pm – 9:30 pm Discussion

FRIDAY

7:30 am – 8:30 am Breakfast

9:00 am Departure

Continue reading “Gordon Conference Program”

AAPT Session: Using the Riches of Astronomy to Teach Physics

Descriptions of invited papers from the 2012  AAPT Winter Meeting Session on “Using the Riches of Astronomy to Teach Physics”

Using Black Holes and Extrasolar Planets to Teach Kepler’s Laws

Tue 02/07, 8:00AM – 8:30AM
by Seth Hornstein
Type: Invited
Two popular topics in an introductory astronomy course are supermassive black holes and extrasolar planets. In this talk, I will discuss two labs/recitation activities that can be used to harness this interest to teach orbital properties. In the first activity, students are provided with a Lego Orrery (as designed by the Kepler Mission Education team) and, using a light sensor and computer, develop a relationship between orbital radius and period as well as a relationship between extrasolar planet radius and detected light intensity drop. In a second activity, students are given a plot of the orbits of stars around the supermassive black hole (SMBH) at the Galactic Center. Using the actual orbital elements, students use Newton’s version of Kepler’s third law to determine the mass of the SMBH. In both cases, students have reported enjoying the activities due to their portrayal of actual scientific methods and use of research-based data.

Solar Coronal Loops: Faraday Constrained

Tue 02/07, 8:30AM – 9:00AM
by Gordon Emslie
Type: Invited
Images of solar coronal loops in ultraviolet and X-ray radiation are used to motivate a discussion of Faraday’s law of induction. Even though the resistivity of the solar atmosphere is similar to that of copper, the huge (~100,000 km) extent of a solar active region makes the overall resistance very small. Further, there is a limit to how much current can flow ? the limiting current density is given by the charge density times the local sound speed. This combination of low resistance and finite current severely restricts the voltage differences that can exist, and hence, by Faraday’s law, the speed at which a current element in the solar atmosphere can cross magnetic field lines. As a result, the gas is effectively “frozen-in” to the magnetic field, resulting in the dramatic (and beautiful) manner in which radiating material delineates the loop-like magnetic field geometry of a solar active region.

Measurement of Spherical Balloon Circumference Using Eratosthenes’ Method

Tue 02/07, 9:00AM – 9:10AM
by Seiji Takemae
Type: Contributed
We present an activity, based on Eratosthenes’ method of estimating Earth’s circumference, of measuring the circumference of an inflated rubber balloon. Suction-cup darts are attached to the surface of the balloon along a meridian. The experimental circumference is obtained from multiple measurements of shadows cast by the darts. This measurement is then compared with the circumference obtained using a cloth measuring tape. An assessment of uncertainties is given. The activity presented is suitable for astronomy, physics, or math classes or laboratories.

Kepler’s Second Law and Conservation of Angular Momentum

Tue 02/07, 9:10AM – 9:20AM
by Pari Spolter
Type: Contributed
Kepler’s second law is calculated for 18 planets and asteroids. It is shown that equal areas are swept in equal intervals of time only near the perihelion (P) and the aphelion (A). A highly significant relation between the ratio of the area swept at the average of P and A to the area swept at semimajor (S) in the same interval of time and the eccentricity is presented. The equation is ratio = a.eb+c with a = -0.617, b = 2, and c = 1.00. The correlation coefficient is 0.9975. The ratio is equal to the square root of one minus e square , which is equal to sin theta, where theta is the smaller angle between the two vectors v and r. Angular momentum is a vector perpendicular to the plane formed by v and r and is conserved, indicating that there is no torque in the direction vertical to the plane of the orbits.

Detecting the Cosmic Microwave Background in Cosmos & Classroom

Slides: Detectors for the Cosmic Microwave Background at the Frontier of Cosmology and in the Classroom
Slides: Detectors for the Cosmic Microwave Background at the Frontier of Cosmology and in the Classroom

Dr. John Kovac, Assistant Professor of Astronomy and Physics at Harvard University, presented a two-part talk. First, he gave a gripping account of detector development, installation, and use at the South Pole Telescope; then he described his course in which undergraduates build a microwave horn, assemble the necessary electronics, and detect the cosmic microwave background.

Detecting the Cosmic Microwave Background at the Frontier of Cosmology and in the Classroom

Author: John Kovac  (Harvard University, Departments of Astronomy and of Physics)

The 3K blackbody Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), while exceedingly faint, is the most abundant light in the Universe, permeating all of space as a relic of the hot, dense, primordial fireball. Its detection in 1965 established the Big Bang as the standard model of cosmology and earned its co-discoverers Penzias and Wilson a Nobel Prize. Over the past two decades, advances in detector technology driven by CMB research have produced telescopes with ever-increasing numbers of photon background-limited microwave detectors, capable of mapping fine structure of the CMB to micro-Kelvin precision. These have had enormous impact, determining the geometry of the universe, quantifying the dark matter and dark energy that dominate it, and detecting the faint polarization arising from the primordial seeds of structure. The current frontier is defined by new arrays of thousands of superconducting, polarized detectors producing maps approaching nano-Kelvin precision. In this decade, these measurements will answer questions about the physics driving the earliest moments of the Big Bang and will survey the large-scale structure of the universe, determining neutrino masses and constraining the nature of dark energy. The advanced detector technology fueling this frontier provides superb device-physics training for graduate students and postdocs working on current-generation CMB telescopes. At the same time, careful experimental techniques developed for CMB observations can now be combined with inexpensive high-quality satellite TV detectors to allow even undergraduates to detect the CMB, reproducing Penzias and Wilson’s famous discovery. I describe one such undergraduate class at Harvard, which builds CMB telescopes from scratch in a few weeks with a modest budget, teaching students about microwave techniques and detectors and allowing them to find their own evidence for the Big Bang.  — SLIDES

Coupling physics to understanding the performance of detector arrays

A course sequence in Detector Array Theory, Camera Building, and System Testing.
Slides: A course sequence in Detector Array Theory, Camera Building, and System Testing.

Dr. Zoran Ninkov, Professor in the Center for Imaging Science at Rochester Institute of Technology, described his year-long course in which his students learn and use basic physics and engineering to design and build a working CCD camera. For more information, see his A full-year university course sequence in Detector Array Theory, Camera Building, and System Testing.

Coupling physics to understanding the performance of detector arrays
Author:  Zoran Ninkov (Rochester Institute of Technology)

Over the last few decades developments in microelectronics have led to the development of arrays of detectors that can be used to measure unprecedentedly small levels of signal. Such arrays have been used to detect electromagnetic radiation ranging in energy from the X-ray through sub-millimeter wavelengths and also particles. Perhaps nowhere have the improvements been more astonishing than in devices available for the visible part of the spectrum (400 — 1000 nm). The most successful detector array in this spectral region is the Charge Coupled Detector (CCD) whose inventors were recognized with the Nobel Prize in Physics in 2009. In this talk I will review some of the detectors and technologies that are used in low light level imaging. I will also describe a full year sequence of classes (i.e. a theory class, a CCD camera building class and a CCD camera performance measurement class) that students at the Rochester Institute of Technology can take to make them knowledgeable as to the physics underlying the operation and performance of such detector arrays. Finally I will discuss the associated laboratory classes that students must take to measure the performance of the camera they have built and what aspects of fundamental physics are integrated into their understanding. These classes have been taken by both calculus and non-calculus trained students. The classes appeal to students with both types of backgrounds as it couples an understanding of physics to something that they build and use.  — SLIDES

Gamma-ray bursts, black holes, exoplanets: How CCD Detectors have Revolutionized Astronomy

Gamma-ray Bursts, Black Holes, and Exoplanets: How CCD Detectors have Revolutionized Astronomy
Slides: Gamma-ray Bursts, Black Holes, and Exoplanets: How CCD Detectors have Revolutionized Astronomy

Dr. George Ricker, Senior Research Scientist in MIT’s Kavli Institute for Astrophysics and Space Research, described the work of four of his graduate students. Detector development was central to the Ph. D. education of each, opened new frontiers, and led to a career and leadership in astronomy or space science.

Gamma-ray Bursts, Black Holes, and Exoplanets: How CCD Detectors have Revolutionized Astronomy
Author:  George Ricker (Massachusetts Institute of Technology)

I will tell the story of my research group’s role in the development of astronomical charge-coupled detectors (CCDs) by relating the contributions of four MIT research students to projects which we have undertaken together over the past three decades. These projects have empowered observations extending over four decades of the electromagnetic spectrum, enabling discoveries ranging from gamma-ray burst emitting collapsars at cosmological distances, to accretion-driven black holes in the Galaxy, and to exoplanets in the solar neighborhood. This story will illustrate the key contributions which student researchers can make when a novel detector technology arrives on the scene. Finally, I will also describe some of the ways in which their early education in these possibilities has impacted my students’ future careers as astronomers and experimental physicists.  — SLIDES

Basic physics of astronomical detectors

The basic physics of astronomical detectors Our Eyes on the Universe
Slides: The basic physics of astronomical detectors: Our Eyes on the Universe

The lead-off speaker, Dr. James Beletic, Director of Astronomy & Civil Space at Teledyne Imaging Sensors (TIS), also chaired the session. He gave a fine overview of optical and infrared detectors and their physics.

The basic physics of astronomical detectors, our eyes on the Universe
Author:   James Beletic (Teledyne Imaging Sensors)

The universe is an amazingly huge place. While humankind has directly explored Earth’s sister planets with space probes, we don’t have the means to venture beyond the solar system, and so almost all information about the universe comes from sensing light that happens our way. Astronomy is constantly striving to find better ways to sense the feeble amount of energy from distant stars and galaxies. This quest has led to a new generation of large telescopes on the ground and in space. Possibly more important than the development of bigger telescopes is the rapid advancement in solid state detector technology. In the x-ray, visible and infrared wavelengths, the most advanced detectors are based on two fundamental technologies: (1) nearly perfect detector materials that efficiently convert photon energy to electrical charge, and (2) very sensitive transistors that convert a few electrons into a measurable voltage. This talk presents the basic physics of astronomical detectors and provides an introduction to the more specialized talks that follow in this session of presentations. Since detectors of light are critical to nearly every aspect of scientific research and involve a wide range of physical phenomena, this session of talks will provide the audience with physics lessons that can be readily incorporated in an undergraduate physics curriculum.        — SLIDES